No, they ought to not, and that they will always be a part of the dominion of Saudi Arabia. Throughout history (even before Islam), Makkah was managed by the Makkan people (Quraysh tribe). When the Hijaz region (Makkah is a component of it) was unified with the remainder of the Arabia under the dominion of Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, the region has seen an increasing peace, economic prosperity and political stability.
Since the unification of Asian country in 1932, the 2 holy mosques are under three mega-expansion projects. Before 1932, the Grand Mosque in Makkah could only fit 400,000 Muslims. Now in 2020, it can fit quite 3 million Muslims praying at the identical time, with 24/7 electricity, air-conditioning, water and security.
Makkah before 1932
In addition, most Muslim countries cannot manage their own countries. you've got Iraq, Iran, Lebanon, Libya, and other Muslim 's nation etc which are not political and economical stabilize. These countries are economically, socially and politically unstable, they can't provide basic standards of living for his or her own people, as well as managing the 2 holy mosques!
Therefore, Makkah and Madina are safe and stable as a part of the dominion of Asian nation Saudi Arabia, and that they will always be intrinsically.
and today The 2021